Shop by category

Personalized gifts

View all

Shop with a few of our vendors

Every purchase supports local small business owners — dozens of local makers, all under one roof in downtown Crawfordsville.

How personalization works

  • 1. Pick a piece

    Browse our personalized gifts and choose the piece you love — jewelry, leatherette, an ornament, a plaque or drinkware.

  • 2. Add your text or design

    Tell us the name, date, message or artwork you want — in store, or with your order notes.

  • 3. We engrave it for you

    We personalize it in our Crawfordsville shop — and let you know when it is ready to pick up.

Workshops & Classes

Want a private workshop or party?

Book a private workshop or party for your group — we will help you pick the project and set the date.

Book a Party

Stuff A Plush

Host a Stuff A Plush birthday party in our shop — $35 per child for a 16-inch plush, with a free heart insert and birth certificate.

Book a Party

Visit us

Shop Small Shop Handmade
124 N Green St
Crawfordsville, IN 47933
Phone: 765-307-2501
Hours: Mon, Tue, Thu, Fri: 9 AM–5 PM
Wed & Sat: 10 AM–2 PM
Closed Sunday